Announcing the Journal of Mechanical Design 2024 Editors’ Choice Paper Awards and Honorable Mentions
The Journal of Mechanical Design is pleased to announce the two (2) winners for the Journal of Mechanical Design 2024 Editors’ Choice Paper Award and two (2) Honorable Mentions.
TRIZ Contradiction Analysis for Creative Design for Additive Manufacturing Practice
Undergraduate engineering students are expected to develop strong design and professional skills. These skills are often difficult to teach and assess effectively throughout a degree program. This article examines how design education develops from introductory courses through capstone design within undergraduate programs and highlights the need for structured and repeated formative assessment. The study synthesizes evidence from multiple institutions to capture diverse approaches to teaching and assessing engineering design. Their findings show that while programs consistently introduce hands-on teamwork and problem-solving experiences, many programs lack consistent formative feedback and structured reflection needed for real skill development. Survey data, public information, and faculty vignettes were leveraged to reveal that most programs assess design outcomes rather than the learning process itself. Multiple design projects, frequent feedback, and iterative reflection opportunities are recommended in order to reinforce what students learn about the engineering design process over time. In addition, the work calls for better integration of professional skills into undergraduate design experiences. These findings invite educators to rethink how design learning evolves, ensuring that skill development continues well beyond the classroom and prepares future engineers to meet the complex, multidisciplinary challenges of modern practice.